Comment by wtv I on Shirayukihime ni Kuchizuke - Vol.2 Chapter 6

@wtv I  not mom but for sister's surgery abroad and look He didn't betrayed Asuka, if it weren't for his job, who'd listen to such disgusting thing?? if he had helped Asuka he had betrayed his employer, which is not right!!! you're just seeing it mc's pov which is just natural cuz anyone would but side characters have life too even though it's not shown !! honestly, if my brother's on death bed, and i was in Shinoda's place, that could've been saved my brother's life, i would've done the same !!!! i respect yer opinion too, i hope it don't offend ya

@wtv I  I totally agree with you! First I tried to gave him excuses but in the end I came to conclusion that he's doing it for his selfish reasons, like seriously, taking part it selling a child and setting him to get raped many times over the years is just madness, nobody sane would think he cared, he could reported this since he could easily collect evidence, but he continued to get benefited from a child getting raped. I'm also thinking about the sister, if I was in her place i would rather die than to be treated with that kind of money.

@Shruti in the first place accepting help from "dirty money" is wrong. Let just say yau at his shoes and your boss ask you to ra** the kid in exchange for money. Do you do it?? If you can do it you're not human, you're just a slave to money. They're still a lot of way to get money. Everyone has their fate. If my family die because I can't afford to send them aboard then it is what it is. I be sad but that's it, it's my fault that bad at making monkey. I am not gonna sacrifice or betraying someone for money

@Fried chicken I mean to agree but I press the wrong button 😭

@Hime Shira i believe no one's a saint in this era !! you may have heard that " blood's thicker than water", ofcourse my family is precious, i may as well fight from grim reaper for them !! you may not believe it, but i'm in hospital rn with an iv drip in my hand, i faimted my father rushed to the hospital so why not me ?? and yk if there's a way and i can't save my family, it's my fault !! and if i were in his place, suppose i didn't have betrayed Asuka and interuppted his so-called father, then what would've happen to me?? i'm just a nobody in front of his father's wealth and power, he would've killed me and have left no trace !! i proudly say i'm not a saint, i don't believe in other person's welfare before mine and my family ! i'm cruel, i'm inhumane cuz i see world with eyes not heart !! if you're this much saint, try giving your every ounce of money and food to those who have none , ever done that? no?? i've done that ! i don't earn but i do give people food and money when i have !!

@Shruti look. no one said they want to be a saint. I am not gonna give money or food to someone I don't care, they're can be starving and dead on a sidewalk and I still don't care about them. And I see the world with eye not heart too. I am not stupid enough to sacrifice myself for others but at least I know when or to who I can be cruel. It just my morals not to hurt or betray someone innocent (who doesn't deserve to be treated like this and they important for me) even if it cost my own life. Maybe I even more cruel than you because I don't care if they're my own family or not but I still not gonna break my own rule for them.

In this case, let's say this child is innocent and he's dear to me, he's not different than my family but why sacrifice him? Because he's not your biological family? Because he still alive after being raped again and again and maybe for the rest of his life? Hey I don't blame anyone. At this topic no one is wrong. But if a family is your excuse to hurt someone then will you hurt your best friend that is dear to you? So in the end they're not important to you? The answer is everyone personal opinion and no one is wrong or even true. This kind of question is illusion that usually test your morals. 

In this is my answer: in this case if I were in that secretary shoes. I will refuse his father help. In the first place my sister is my own responsibility I don't need someone giving me dirty money. If my sister end up dead then it's my own fault. Am I sacrifice my sister then? Maybe I am not sure myself. You can judge all you want for not accepting that dirty money.

@Hime Shira and you think that by helping that boy you won ? He'll kill both of you and then what? You killed yourself and that boy too ? In this story the boy's enough smart to escape but what he chose ? To be his father's s** toy !? Is it Shinoda's fault ? In saint's eyes, yeah it is!! Shinoda has no one he** of a connection, he's just doing his job which is be Asuka's escort and guard, did that say be his father ? Be his brother? It's his or that person's choice ! Or maybe you're in an environment where your family hasn't given you one he** of a love !

@Shruti bruh why you saying like I blame your pov?  I already said it's nothing wrong with your answer and I believe nothing wrong with my answer.
Stop saying I try to be a saint pls. I just don't want to give other burden because of my irresponsibility and what's wrong with that? My family is just fine. I love them and they love me. But as a human I have principle and moral. And I have brain to do something not just watching and waiting for the person I love like family lives a miserable life 

The point is that guy doesn't do anything after years, he just watch with stupid regret and guilt buried in his heart, same with the kid mother. And how is the kid smart enough to escape? he never escape!! Until to the point he feel he doesn't need to escape and he try to justify his father action. If not because of his friend. He never broke free by himself and no one gonna help him. 

If you read the next chapter (I already read them in Chinese ver) the kid never blame anyone but he hurt so much he doesn't feel anything anymore. And what the guy do?  I am not gonna say it because it's spoiler. 

If you want to be this guy go ahead. He's not wrong. If what he did is correct for you. That's fine too I am not you. And you're not me. I can judge you like you judge me. Just remember if someday you be in similar position with that kid.... maybe your answer gonna be different.

After this I am not gonna reply. Just press 💢 emoji if you really hate my comment. This is pointless debate anyway. I apologize if I offend you.

@Hime Shira it's an indeed impolite discussion, but i plan to carve my way of life that pest won't be even able to see my life let alone this thing !!! but you write too much, english ain't my first language, so i have troubles expressing my views, not to mention can't find the true word is one he** of a big problem !! you don't need to apolozise since this was a matters of opinions, no one should be punished or feel sorry for what they're thinking !! let's not be each other's enemy !