I think both the headmaster and the dark magic guy are at fault here. You cant simply put the blame on one of them - they equally made their own bad decisions. Even though the author tried to convince us with fluff and how the headmaster built a school for his dead wife, it still doesn't change the fact that he put his wife into the experiment in the first place. The dark magic guy already had motives at the beginning of experiment to use Erina's and Alpheas's memories for his organisms or whatever, so he isn't completely innocent either. I guess it's up to the reader who they find to be in the better person is. I personally think that its alpheas because he at least tried to live up for his actions, and dark magic guys tried to twist the story to make Alpheas the villain. Thanks for reading my rant lol.
lol im too young for this