TBH, there's a reason this manhwa has a surprising amount of fanfiction, and it's because the way Lloyd and Javier are written is genuinely amazing. The bond these two have is unbelievably well written, and literally any romance with this amount of depth and build up would be legendary.
I think that's kind of why people want this to be BL so badly. A lot of romances are written in a way that makes the romance kind of get in it's own way. People get doki-doki over people they barely know, or they don't really earn the moments they have together. Here we can literally see Lloyd and Javier grow close over time without any pressure for them to get closer before the audience gets bored. These two grow to genuinely and honestly care for each other on a timeline that makes sense for when they started. If you like romance, this is genuinely a better foundation for it than most dedicated romance manhwa.
We also spend a lot more time with Javier than Alicia, so it's not really a surprise that people prefer him. He's more familiar and we know him better.