Comment by JustWatching on One Piece - Chapter 1084

Comment on ChapterOne Piece - Chapter 1084
Read this on reddit and I thought it was an interesting theory.

What if Amazon Lily is where Queen Lily went as she was the founder of that kingdom. Aside from the name it also fits the snake motif they got going on.

6 Replies

@JustWatching

what's interesting in this theory ?

@pi23 That Amazon Lily and Arabasta kingdom has a shared history which adds more depth to the current lore. Also creates a possbility that both royal family's share then same ancestor.

If this is supposedly true then it begs the question of why Queen Liliy didn't or couldn't return back to Arabasta kingdom. This then leads into another question that if the former is true then why did she make the decisions that she did. Hence it adds more mystery and intrigue to what happend 800 years ago that the world government was so desperate to bury.
@JustWatching

I think everything else would be enriching x) also there's already a mistery about her disepearrance and also about why Im pronounced her name like he knew her. So adding again another mistery is a bit much i think x).

But well one piece is a detailed story with many intircaties, so two similars names are suspicious I agree with that.

Maybe Im dumped her x).

Whatever it's obvious that the only family not following the actions of the 19 other kingdoms would have a reason and her diseappearing like that might be related. That I found it interesting but her maybe being the founder of amazon lily not really... Like she could have been the founder of whatever else and above all if she left any legacy or knowledge of her era behind her that'd be amazing and i don't think the place where it'd be left or the people inherinting it would be this "ordinary"

@JustWatching And when you consider the island is a tropical jungle surrounded by a calm belt and huge sea kings, makes the PERFECT exile location to just "die" to the outside world.
@pi23 lili had the ope ope no mi and forced to perform immortality on Im