Comment by Kristin on Home page

Comment on DiscussionHome page
Can someone of the extremely open minded and inclusive gen tell me what exactly is a woman to you? Not some person that identifies as a woman, because to identify as a woman you need to know what a woman is and why you identify as one. I ask because I had an argument with a colleague and her trans friend last week and couldnt stop thinking about it. My friend has a trans friend, we were introduced, this is my friend x, this is my friend y. Everything was okay until the trans girl said she went to a date with a cis girl, which is weird to me but not that relevant, just a curious detail, and she was mad that the girl called her trans, said something about her date saying a friend told her he had a trans girl to introduce to her, if she was interested. Trans woman said she was just a woman, not a trans woman so I was like okay. Then she said "like, you are a cis woman, but I am just woman too" and I was like hold up, I am a cis woman but you are just a woman? And there my friend said trans woman are just woman, to which I said sure, you are right, but if trans women are just women then "cis" women are just women too, not cis. You want to call me a cis woman but call a trans just woman? Are you saying the word woman goes to trans and biological women are now cis? Natural born females lost the right to be called women and now shall be called cis, but natural born males that identify as women are the new real women?
I totally support trans women being just women, but if they are just women then so am I. And if you want to call me cis, then trans women are trans, not just women. So you choose, we are both women, JUST WOMEN, or I am cis and they are trans. You gotta choose one, cannot have them both. Trans girl called me insensitive, maybe I am, but I do not think I am wrong

9 Replies

@Kristin that person is not worth your time and definitely not worth your distress. Some ppl just can't stop thinking they are oh so entitled n what not. If I explain it differently I would say these kind of ppl would think they have it hard but if u share how hard it is for you , they will rush to hush u n belittle your struggle
Diablo
DiabloCommander·9 months ago
@Kristin If they have dih.. they r man if they have lip they r women. Thats it any other thing its just mental illness.ITS scientifically proven but i love everyody opinions.
@Kristin You born either a male or female or both other than that is just fetish. Yup i said it LGBTQ+ are just fetish. I dont mind if you had that kind of fetish but dont force other people to accept it as gender because it not
BiNShy
BiNShyGeneral·9 months ago
@Kristin trans women know they are trans though and don't mind being called as such, she's just weird or this story is made up. I'm a cis woman too
@BiNShy I'm not a cis, I'M A FREAKING WOMAN. And trans do get this idea that we should get a tag to our female status
No made up, all true, trans girl hate me.
BiNShy
BiNShyGeneral·9 months ago
@Kristin it's just an adjective! It's the opposite to trans which is also an adjective, if you aren't cis you're trans so congrats on coming out, I support you