Comment by Kazooie on cae

Comment on Replycae
@cae You're a girl, you should be against Islam. Go look up how old Aisha was when their prophet raped her. Go look into Safiyya Bint Huyay. Go look up the very fact that they allow 'correction' against women. Go look up 'thighing'. This is what they are.

1 Reply

@Kazooie let me refute but i believe hadith is definitely has been changed due to passing it down orally for 300 years. you say to look up when aisha was raped? it says 9 in google and the sahih stated in was bukhari 5134 but there also another sahhi bukhari 476 stated that by aisha that I had seen my parents following Islam since I attained the age of intelligence. meaning she was old enough to think for herself which contradicts that she was 6 yo by the time she married the prophet. as i say hadith is the words of men so quite true it can be changed in 300 years. For the correction against women i think you mean to quote 4.34 that say if you fear high-handedness from your wives, remind them [of the teachings of G**], then ignore them when you go to bed, then hit them. If they obey you, you have no right to act against them: G** is most high and great. please read the whole things and learn it is related to trying to swindled the money of an orphan under your care. thighing is for when the wife is too young. tbh it say in quran that permissable marriage age is related to Test ˹the competence of˺ the orphans until they reach a marriageable age 4.6. meaning until they are able to think competencely for themself they are not allow to marry which is usually around 17. thighing allow you to have some sexual pleasure even to baby that you married so does that sound like something quran allow when it clearly states has them test competence? tbh thighing is not even permissible to some case but it pass so is it the fault of the religion that said no but people go with it? also both party needs competent mind and consent or else the marriage is not even legal.