So here is my feeling or my take or opinion on this. He love her but got stuck in the triangle of the friendship and fiance. He's Ophelia fiance as her parent adopted him there just to be their son-in-law. But Ophelia saw him as a friend and no more than that so he got no chance to propose to his love. But here is my take, why and why and why (infinite why if I could) would he don't try to make them treated Emilia better? As you all saw all those chapters before. Emilia was bought to be Ophelia friend but they just became real family in the time. So he didn't try to make them treated her better than "a friend we bought for our daughter" because she was only there for Ophelia, since she got no one to cherished except her/Ophelia. When we got connections somewhere, we still got stuck in feelings because of that, so he didn't try either so why he talked like "yeah I'm better than you so let me talk to her" here? All the male leads are trash and trash, he isn't better than them. Not considered the point that he only treated Elodi as Ophelia "double body" and no more. I just don't want them all to burn after Emilia declined them all and be happy with Elodi. THEY BOTH DESERVE BETTER.
Comment by M A I on The Bad Ending of an Otome - Chapter 45
3 Replies
@M A I Hi there 😁
i would like to point out that Mc was't mistreated in any way ? Ophelia parent did'nt saw her like their daughter sure and the Marquess had a verry awfull reaction when Emilia calld her Mom that one time and said a trully cruel thing; wich by the way is cruel but understandable from her perspective ) but other that Mc was well taken care of in general. Everyone in that house was deeply respectfull toward her. you can't expect Ophelia parent to consider her like familly by default or anything,like you said yourself they tooked her in to be their sick daughter companion,they actually don't owe her familly love ? I understand that we feel bad for the Mc and that the society at larged considered her as Ophelia shadow wich suck , but they where all blinded by Ophelia "Godess'' halo apparently.
But again no one was unfair mean or cruel to Emilia in general. So on what ground Rarethis should have made Ophelia parent "treat" Mc better exactly ? did you expect Ophelia fiancé to tell to her parrent that they have to love their daughter companion ? It's clearly not his place or any one else for the matter because you can't force something like love. the situation did't call for any actuall reasonable action. he didn't do anything because there where nothing to be done in the first place. By the way he was a literal child when Mc was still hopping to get maternal love. Like realisticly even if he knew (wich is not even sure )of what happened that day with the marquioness what could have he done ? it's not a child role to help an adult (marquesse) to cope with depression. Curently every main carracters are 18 years old they are teenagers mc is a grown adult but the other a just that children.
i would like to point out that Mc was't mistreated in any way ? Ophelia parent did'nt saw her like their daughter sure and the Marquess had a verry awfull reaction when Emilia calld her Mom that one time and said a trully cruel thing; wich by the way is cruel but understandable from her perspective ) but other that Mc was well taken care of in general. Everyone in that house was deeply respectfull toward her. you can't expect Ophelia parent to consider her like familly by default or anything,like you said yourself they tooked her in to be their sick daughter companion,they actually don't owe her familly love ? I understand that we feel bad for the Mc and that the society at larged considered her as Ophelia shadow wich suck , but they where all blinded by Ophelia "Godess'' halo apparently.
But again no one was unfair mean or cruel to Emilia in general. So on what ground Rarethis should have made Ophelia parent "treat" Mc better exactly ? did you expect Ophelia fiancé to tell to her parrent that they have to love their daughter companion ? It's clearly not his place or any one else for the matter because you can't force something like love. the situation did't call for any actuall reasonable action. he didn't do anything because there where nothing to be done in the first place. By the way he was a literal child when Mc was still hopping to get maternal love. Like realisticly even if he knew (wich is not even sure )of what happened that day with the marquioness what could have he done ? it's not a child role to help an adult (marquesse) to cope with depression. Curently every main carracters are 18 years old they are teenagers mc is a grown adult but the other a just that children.
Par 2 Also we tend to forget that Mc is not a reliable narattor at all. Since that day with the Marquioness she cut all possible feeling she could have to anything that is not Ophelia. therfore she treat other like they don't matter and treat herself like she can't possibly have an impact in their life when she literally grew up with them.. She's the one who choosed to became Ophelia Shadow and not interact in a meanngfull way with anyone. You can't blame Rarethis for that especially because he didn't treat her as ophelia double. In this timeline he always was in love with Mc and treated her as a friend. Mc is the one who pushed him away the entire time because she did't wanted to be "greedy" unlike blondie who developed an intrest to mc only after Ophelia death he always saw her.
Dont get me wrong i wishe she could just end up with Ophelia to me me she clearly was Mc true love; but i think we giving some Ml way to much cr** for thing they had no say in the first place.
of course the guy in glasses is disgusting and deserved nothing else than a painfull death but they are not all Trash. Rarethis is the only one who literally did't do anything wrong in this timeline and blond guy ignore Mc for the longest time but that again is not specially vill or anything. As for the original timeline The story make it verry clear that there is some realy fu** up magical godess bullshit which compel everyone to whorship Ophelia and not seeing her as a human,therfor cutting her from her humanity and in result becoming less human in the literal sense blondie explain that Mc somehow made her human in the current timeline. Mc think it's bullshit but it's most likely true.
Dont get me wrong i wishe she could just end up with Ophelia to me me she clearly was Mc true love; but i think we giving some Ml way to much cr** for thing they had no say in the first place.
of course the guy in glasses is disgusting and deserved nothing else than a painfull death but they are not all Trash. Rarethis is the only one who literally did't do anything wrong in this timeline and blond guy ignore Mc for the longest time but that again is not specially vill or anything. As for the original timeline The story make it verry clear that there is some realy fu** up magical godess bullshit which compel everyone to whorship Ophelia and not seeing her as a human,therfor cutting her from her humanity and in result becoming less human in the literal sense blondie explain that Mc somehow made her human in the current timeline. Mc think it's bullshit but it's most likely true.
Par 3 The only reason she could treat Ophelia as a human is because she is not from this world but everyone else woud't be able to see anything else than Ophelia so to a certain extent they are not fully responsable for ignoring Mc at first or the harrasing of ophelia to. I hate to say that somone is not responsable for their action especially stuff like stalking and obsession but weirdly enough in this story a part of it is because of the godess compelling cr**.
Well yet again a part not all of it that why glassess dude can go die in both timeline.
there is a lot of thing Mc and the readers don't know about this world yet. Keep in mind that Mc doe's not actually know anyone in this universe because she had clouded vision by her idea of them in the games and activly refuse to learn anything about them to. Mc spend a lot of time in her own head. But because of that we don't actually know the characters or their circumstences
With all that said she still should end up with Ophelia bacause Rarethis is borring and look way to much like her in this artstyle everytime i look at them i feel like they are sibeling like 😐 and Blondie is anoying and Glassess can go die for real 👹
Viva the yurie road
Well yet again a part not all of it that why glassess dude can go die in both timeline.
there is a lot of thing Mc and the readers don't know about this world yet. Keep in mind that Mc doe's not actually know anyone in this universe because she had clouded vision by her idea of them in the games and activly refuse to learn anything about them to. Mc spend a lot of time in her own head. But because of that we don't actually know the characters or their circumstences
With all that said she still should end up with Ophelia bacause Rarethis is borring and look way to much like her in this artstyle everytime i look at them i feel like they are sibeling like 😐 and Blondie is anoying and Glassess can go die for real 👹
Viva the yurie road