Because only Carcel who had loved you since from the beginning of all the 4 timelines. please remember it faster and please understand Carcel's pov too
Comment by Umi Is My Name on The Broken Ring : This Marriage Will Fail Anyway - Chapter 58
3 Replies
@Umi Is My Name it's actually 3...1st life where she committed suicide as Oscar's wife... 2nd life when she met emiliano and had a kid with him but yeah... And then this 3rd life where she woke up not as a 16 year old but as a child.
@Ghost in the Novel, it will be revealed that this isnt her 3rd life, but her 4th.
She doesnt remember because Oscar turned back time/asked the angel for the memories of his past life in which ( ines's real first life) she was married to Carcel, and they loved each other very very much.
Oscar was jelous and wanted Ines then, so he retained his memories and turned the time. He stole Ines from Carcel in her second life( the life where she marries the Crown Prince Oscar) but Ines believes that that is her first life. Thats also the reason why Oscar Rapes Ines every time after he sees that Ines amd Carcel exchanged a few words.
Later after she meets a priest, falshbacks of her real first life will be revealed to her, because she "chose right" this time. And so she'll see that truly, Carcel has always loved her, in each and every timeline, Carcel loved her deeply
@Mangareader OMG WHAT?!?! OMGGGG,, thank you for correcting me and telling me this. OMFGG SERIOUSLY?! Goshdang