Comment by aressssss on Infinite Mage - Chapter 27

Comment on ChapterInfinite Mage - Chapter 27

some of y'all are UNREAL with this hate on amy bruh, like she's got flaws and shes done some selfish stuff but you're acting like she killed shirone's parents 😭😭 my g** why do you guys think character development EXIST

i only read romance manhwas for the beautiful women. scummy male leads can DIE

6 Replies

But I get it... Like the trauma she leaves in readers minds is real and in consideration of her thought process there is obviously hope for her. Although to clarify she hasn't truly had a moment of redemption when it comes to her and Shirone, just reactions to the consequences of her actions. She hasn't actually made up for her past behavior, choosing instead to refuse even apologizing to him and to threaten him. Reflection is not cause for absolution, just because she thinks things over doesn't mean she is forgiven.

This has officially been my longest comment ever. Also I am in no way trying to denounce your opinion but it does stand to reason why some still currenly dislike Amy as a character.pepe sticker

Ryip
Ryip·3y ago

I was more traumatized lately by assh**** like the emperor from "I gave birth to the tyrant children" and quite toxic characters such as the FL from "newly wed life of a witch and a dragon" than Amy. Truth to be told, she's as cunning and hilarious than young Naruto trying stupid things and failing, yet she's way cooler and badass. I quite like her a tad more than Sakura all along the first season (only role = Sasuke's tedious "love interest" and be the damzelle in distress). Or I can compare her with Elza from Fairy Tails : hot headed, strong, even frightening and dangerous, but at the same time as mischievous and misguided than Natsu and or Gray with a pinch of dishonnesty like Lucy.

To sum up, I'm already laughing plenty thanks to Amy Karmis 👍😂

Ohh yeah I can see that but still stand by what I said considering it is a statement made only in reference to this manhwapepe sticker

@Holycole yes i completely understand and agree with what you have said, with amy not having had her real moment of redemption yet;; however, with that in mind, do we even fully understand her as a character? her upbringing, childhood, privilege and everything in between all attribute to her personality and her actions, which are all the opposite of shirone. 

i feel like this manhwa is just too green to be blindly hating on the character, as amy has not been given nearly as much sympathy or time as we've had with shirone. i understand a dislike but to literally curse her out in the comments? i feel like it's mostly just people disliking her without really trying to understand where she's coming from.

of course, not tryna diss anyone who dislikes her, because yeah it's kind of none of my bees, and you might actually have a valid reason for disliking her, but it's only been 27 chapters.

i really appreciate how respectful you were with your point, because i know some people would just fly into a rage and cuss me out as well. hope you have a nice day bro 🙏

Oh guess I wasn't clear... I don't exactly like her or hate her, just thought someone should show both sides of an argument and your commment got me thinkingpepe stickerand I totally agree with the no need for toxic comments. There is a point in which I wish for hellfire to rain on a character and she hasn't earned that from mepepe sticker

Ryip
Ryip·3y ago

We all have our sensitivity regarding characters and yes there's no needs to be toxic in comments at such early stage 😌
I think this "hellfire" might take place and form in a way most haters don't await.
Not reading the novel but just a theory

Spoiler!
Should Amy Karmis be already hooked on Shirone (she's dishonest but at the same time overprotective and extremely praising about Shirone), if Shirone was for instance injuried because of her in any way (i.e.: commoner origin and reputation getting Shirone expelled or even threatened to death penality, physical injuries or poisoning threatening his life, etc), I smell she would already/surely first snap then immediately break to the point of hating herself and wanting to die. In a way that sort of things could become her worst punishment but it's questionable whether such thing would take place this early in the story.

Amy's punishment might probably take the form of backfiring but I think she'd rather go through he** herself and come out unscathed the least than something like I imagine happen. I'm sure the damages would be worse to her mind if Shirone tell her "I hate you" than anything more spectacular at first.