Comment by Kukuruku on Gleren

Comment on ReplyGleren
@Gleren quite aggressive reply, but I thank you nonetheless for it.

I was referring to "black and white" as if you only read manga/stories that you like.

In your line of thought, I think you are one of the people who like the ending of Game of Thrones or the Rings of Power just because they were made by someone. Even though, both are just a mockery compared to the original stories they "parodied".

Just because someone has made something, doesn't mean that it has innate good value in itself. And if the holes of the plot are so big that it needs other people to defend them, then I think the story would require a rewrite.

Good stories are worth remembering, bad ones, are dismissed and forgotten.

There is no one person whom is good on everything. I'm good on my job, medium on my hobby and have 2 left hands on a lot of things. Still, if I make something bad, people will tell and I'll try to understand the problem and correct it. This is how life works.

I didn't complain about the lack or too much fiction in the Manga. My problem is with the consistency of the presented logic.

1 Reply

@Kukuruku I don't see my reply as an aggressive one, you're the one who decided to assume that it was. 

Besides, how can you be so sure that I only read stories that I like? Have you been with me while I read stories as they were?

I think you were the one who only like to read stories that you like. My proof? Bad ones should be dismissed and forgotten as you said? Great! There are bad stories precisely because some other stories are above them and they can be compared. Both are meant to be appreciated.

You seem to be so good at words, I admit. But the point is that your missing a good-big-reality. I'm not depending THIS manga as you claimed, I am saying that the plotholes within it, is what makes our brain function to analyze and imagine an alternative rout and outcome. The WHAT IFs.

Tell me then, were there perfect stories that you've read? I'd like to know. Stories are filled with holes—sometimes you just have to fill it yourself.

As you have said, the reality of life cycles with us people having both good and bad at things we do. Sure, good. Very nice. But, don't you see the contradiction between your claims and your words. If you truly believe that there were the factors good and bad at everything people do, then you must understand that this story belong to either one of those. This is story is badly made, how come you cannot tolerate that much? Or are you going to take back your words?

Point is; Stories are meant to be enjoyed. To be appreciated. To be told. Not to be forgotten or dismissed just because you decided and assumed they were bad—only because you find them bad.

Your taste other people's do not always aline. Do not force you unshakable criticism on everyone.