Comment by Antmrm on One Piece - Chapter 1167

Comment on ChapterOne Piece - Chapter 1167
I have a lot of questions about Shank's past. It doesn't make sense to me. Whoever told me about his family is a nobleman? If he was a newborn, remember that. It can't be the Gold Roger Pirates, who were at that event. However, only Dragon knows about his past. No pirate would dream of going to the government to discover their secret, except Doffy, BB's father and son, because they were already acquainted. But how and who gave Shanks the mission to go there? Kaido, BB, and BW never thought of discovering the government's secret. And finally, why did the government let Shanks in if he spent time with Gold Roger and the group on his travels?

6 Replies

@Antmrm shanks was on Roger's crew, clearly he knew something that roger might have learnt at laughtale, something that made him cry.  Shanks is repeatedly described as the child of destiny, he might have took it upon himself to help shape the future pirate king in stead of becoming the king himself like buggy would have wanted. Prophecy is heavily implied in one piece. shanks isnt just a wild horse, he just might have known what roles he had to play from that prophecy
My best guess shanks knew he had to steal the nika df from the hands of wg, that's why he meant to wb when he told him that he bet his arm to the future, aka luffy the goofball who ate the devil fruit
@Antmrm I guess he know that he is a nobel family was from teach's Mother, since shanks mother and teach mother live in the same Island. the time he go back to marijoa was after he got an eye scar from teach soo maybe, teach tell him
@Antmrm Shanks' dad is a CD. A commander of the knights of G** (by this time or sometime shortly after) therefore making him one of the most politically powerful people on the planet. Also insanely rich. Only people above Garling (that we know of at this time) are the Five Elders and Imu. If Garling wants something, no matter how crazy it might seem to someone else, the answer he's going to get is highly unlikely to be no. If he wants Shanks to be in the hierarchy of people with contracts with Imu, it's going to happen. As for who told Shanks about him being noble, I wouldn't be surprised if one of the Rogers Pirates saw Shamrock and put 2 + 2 together. Remember, Roger went to Laughtale which probably had the WG SCREAMING, they would've sent out assassins on Roger's crew. Scooper Gabban all but said he's fought GK before and it wasn't at Gods Valley so the next possibility is that a GK had been sent after him.
@mochaciano wait there is another hole again. who the he** told roger and crew that the baby they found named as shanks tho😯
Only thing I can think of is that the mom had their names sewn into their clothes. Or maybe it was like a corporate event and she had name tags on them XD