Comment by Foregroundeclispe on Jinx - Chapter 64.5

Comment on ChapterJinx - Chapter 64.5
I'm disappointed in Jinx.  I love boxing , I like MMA and Ashita No Joe is such a great story and beautiful tragedy that tells the life of the boxer so perfectly well. I think Ashita No Joe has set my standards so high , that I find Jinx very lacking in terms of  writting and character depth.  And I wish the doctor was a boxer or MMA fighter instead . That would be way more compelling . Both of them as  boxers or MMA fighters, to rivals, and then becoming a couple as the story progressed would be way better in my opinion.  Ashita No Joe is a masterpiece and if you've watched it or read it , you'll know exactly where I'm coming from. I'm dropping this series . I liked their original work BJ Alex , so it's unfortunate that I don't like this series . I wanted to like this series because it had MMA involved and I do like BL . And trust me I tried giving this series a chance . I've read it.  It just doesn't hold up well.  I found a sports series that's way better than Jinx in terms of writting ,character development , and human drama. That series is Ashita No Joe.  Ashita No Joe is a boxing series you all must see for yourself.  It's a timeless classic .  And Jinx lacks the heart and soul . Ashita No Joe has heart and soul . Ashita No Joe is my favorite Anime and Manga series of all time next to Vinland Saga. Hajime No Ippo is pretty good too. I'm a huge fan of boxing so boxing is my favorite sport. But I do like some MMA from time to time.
I'm a transgender man ftm and a gay man. I read all kinds of Manga and Manwha.  My favorites are seinen,  sci-fi , horror , and BL. I do read some shounen as well, mostly very old shounen though .

12 Replies

boom boom
boom boom·1 year ago
@Foregroundeclispe he's an MMA fighter
boom boom
boom boom·1 year ago
@Foregroundeclispe he's an MMA fighter
@boom boom  
Okay I used the wrong term . You got me there.  I made a honest mistake here . But I still stand by on what I said. This story is very disappointing for a sports series in terms of writting and character development. Ashita No Joe is just better written than Jinx. I recommend Ashita No Joe .
Then dont
Then dont·1 year ago
@Foregroundeclispe then dont read jinx if ur just gonn' compare it to other manhwa,we dont need ur opinion so just keep it to urself. Jinx is betterpepe sticker
@Then dont  
Ashita No Joe is a Manga series silly not a manwha. This is just how I feel. If you like the series, more power to you. And no offense,  you are objectively wrong. I know you haven't watched Ashita No Joe or even read it . It's pretty clear from this statement alone . If you read or even watched Ashita No Joe, you'd realize how lacking Jinx is as a story . Jinx is not better than Ashita No Joe .And this is coming from me, a guy who likes BL and sports Manga and sports manwha.  I'm not reading it anymore. It's just my perspective.  
🤦♂️
How can you say Jinx is better when you never read Ashita No Joe or never watched Ashita No Joe's  Anime? You can't make a bold claim like that with no backing for it . I read both Jinx and Ashita No Joe. So I can form an opinion on both series .
Plus you're coming off hostile for no reason.  I'm sorry you feel upset by what I said . Truly. I was just trying to have a discussion.  And we should be allowed to do that. Even if we don't agree with eachother .
Then dont
Then dont·1 year ago
@Foregroundeclispe okay,i dont know what is Ashita blahblah,but dont ever insult jinx,im just offended by what'd you say,cuz im really a fan of jinxpepe sticker
Then dont
Then dont·1 year ago
And dont be disappointed in jinx bcus were offended,we have our own perspectives so if ur just gonna compare is and say jinx is bad,then just dont say it bcuz ur gonna offend a lot of readers