Comment by Swings both ways on Define The Relationship (Yaoi) - Chapter 77

@Swings both ways The one who gave Carlyle the painting plus Ash's biological father (probably)

@Shuthefuckup The eyes are very similar to Ash's eyes, but from what I remember, although Sir Gordon loved Ash's mother very much, he is not the biological father... Ash's mother loved the man she married and he was suspicious of her fidelity, but she never cheated on her husband

@Luna ash mom didn't have an affair. However, she was probably pregnant with ash from her previous lover. That's probably why the man she married kinda didn't accept Ash