Comment by Gazni on I Summoned Her!? - Chapter 8

@Gazni "Any harem that has more than 3 girls is doomed to fail as a manga"
To love ru, Toaru series, Fate series, High school DxD, Shinmai Maou, Maken-ki, Sekirei, Sora no Otoshimono, many other Harem manga anime that has more than 3 girls and become successfull: 'May be we never existed. Our existence is just an illusion, a myth'

@yutomax DxD, Shinmai Maou, Fate seriee and Sora no otoshimono don't have spineless MCs. Heck Fate series is mostly about fighting and most of these mangas, specially Sora no otoshimono shone because of their author's talent. 
Sekirei was meiocre and can be said as a failure of a harem because the emphasis was clearly on the Miko dressed girl. DxD has similar problem but it wasn't as bad and the MC was interesting.

But the rest you mentioned are 'successful' cause the audience was no different from po** addicts. All these mangas had to show for was bobas and more girls. To love-ru was no different from a kid's po**. I stopped reading Maken-ki midway so can't comment on that.

@Gazni Wow first time i heard someone call Toaru series is for po** addict people. Really? Tell me you didn't watch Toaru without telling me you didn't watch Toaru.
"emphasis was clearly on the Miko dressed girl" what wrong with that? DxD emphasis on Rias, Shinmai Maou emphasis on Mio, Sora no otoshimono emphasis on Ikaros. There is no problem with emphasis on a single character at first and than expand out more later. 
Bro, it doesn't matter if these series success for po** addicts or by plot or anything, different author different way, a success is a success. You said "Any harem that has more than 3 girls is doomed to fail as a manga" so i give you example of harem manga that has more than 3 girls got successed. 
Oh and from your first comment, i will assume that you said the mc of this series is spinless or the girls are useless.  Please tell me how the he** did you come up with this when it only been 8 chapter???

@yutomax

"Wow first time i heard someone call Toaru series is for po** "

Ok, I forgot to include Toaru as an exception alongside, Fate series. 

 

" what wrong with that? DxD emphasis on Rias, Shinmai Maou emphasis on Mio, Sora no otoshimono emphasis on Ikaros. There is no problem with emphasis on a single character at first and than expand out more later. "

Expanding is not the problem obviously. The problem is the screentime and depth. If you're gonna keep pushing girls like pokemon captures and treat them like NPCs by doing nothing with them, they are essentially useless. 

 

"DxD emphasis on Rias, Shinmai Maou emphasis on Mio, Sora no otoshimono emphasis on Ikaros. "

Yes but girls is not the only thing they have to show for so I included them as exception. As I have mentioned, the overall plot is good. 

 

"so i give you example of harem manga that has more than 3 girls got successed."

and I have pointed out how their success has less to do with girls and more to do with their other aspects (With the exception of DxD, in this case)

 

"Please tell me how the he** did you come up with this when it only been 8 chapter???"

Patterns obviously. Don't hit me with the 'don't judge a book by it's cover' thing. If a manga can't exhibit any strong points from beginning, obviously no one will stick around to see the rest. So far, the MC has only shown those cliche 'kindness' and 'indecisieness' thing that you see in most harem mangas. 

@Gazni From your answer i will assume your definition of a successfull harem is how you are attract to the girl. So Nisekoi, Gotobun, Oregairu, Oremo, that one show about mc helping 2 girls that best in literature and math, they all have more than 3 girls in the harem and still successfull does it not?

'kindness' does not really connect with 'spinless' man. That just meen he is a good boy, a good man. That all. You can't just judge a mc 'spinless' out of only 8 chapter because he is kind. We haven't even get to know the basic info of all the 7 sins girls yet. No major plot point, no enemy or rival anything. We still in introduction phase. You are too quick on judging. 

As for 'indecisieness', what action give you that impression?

@yutomax  its not a big deal

@yutomax Kindness is when you are not obliged to do it, don't get much out of it compared to the expense, but do it anyway. If he's surrounded by wmen, he's definitely not doing it out of kindness. Almost all of these harem type mangas are all about 'kindness' to heroines. That's not kindness, that's simping. Would he treat a homeless oldmen same way. Huge doubt.