@StarLily501 phew I said a lot, shorter answer is that one, I don't think the young Duke is bad, she doesn't know what he thinks and only sees what he does. Two,The redhead brother was cruel, because he doesn't know how else to help his brother. Three it's from her perspective, so she might see things as one thing but it might be something else entirely. Lastly, the Duke family takes everything she does as face value and think that what she asks of the young Duke is abusing her power to demand attention. Because they aren't close enough to know the underlying reason and because the concubines spins tales of her villainous deeds.