Comment by StarLily501 on suikerplum Pia

Comment on Replysuikerplum Pia
@suikerplum Pia you make some good points, what happened after the poisioning incident yeah that was warrented-i meant more of the cruelty BEFORE hand. and understandable that someone dosen't want excessive feeling thrown at them. Though it is unfair to put that hatred on someone just because she's from a family they hate(beofore the poisoning incident), things are'nt so black and white thsts true but but with the rather negative interactions they had with another I'd still say their nor trust worthy

2 Replies

StarLily501you make some good points, what happened after the poisioning incident yeah that was warrented-i meant more of the…

I mean yes, they were quite hateful. But you can see the young Duke at least tried to get her at first. But he was thought to hate the imperial family. And to his eyes what she was doing was basically use her status as princess to demand his attention. And also, the concubine portrays her as a villain, so they genuinely base off all they know about her in the small interactions that they have. Which have all been rather negative. She's just a child doesn't work, because they were also children and. And The red haired was rather cruel, but he only wanted to protect his brother because seeing him in his predicament (forced marriage) makes him want to help him no matter the cost. They're not going to read into everything she does, they see her every action on face value, because they have no ties whatsoever except for the contract marriage. That's it, I came off rude last time. I don't think you're wrong in defending her. But I really don't see it as a black and white. She's narrating for herself, so she's not accurate and detailed into whatever she's saying because she doesn't even know what other people are thinking in the first place. Maybe the young Duke actually showed care for her, but because she wasn't givenanything to base it off on. She kept asking for more and the small gestures weren't enough for her. Who knows

StarLily501you make some good points, what happened after the poisioning incident yeah that was warrented-i meant more of the…

phew I said a lot, shorter answer is that one, I don't think the young Duke is bad, she doesn't know what he thinks and only sees what he does. Two,The redhead brother was cruel, because he doesn't know how else to help his brother. Three it's from her perspective, so she might see things as one thing but it might be something else entirely. Lastly, the Duke family takes everything she does as face value and think that what she asks of the young Duke is abusing her power to demand attention. Because they aren't close enough to know the underlying reason and because the concubines spins tales of her villainous deeds.